Responsibility to protect, humanitarian intervention and human rights. Since the issue of humanitarian intervention is related to international law, political science, morality. An important component for any theory of humanitarian intervention would be a conception of conditions that make such interventions possible and ensure that participants serve cosmopolitan interests. An inquiry into law and morality 5 1988 because the ultimate justification of the existence of states is the protection and enforcement of the natural rights of the citizens, a government that engages in substantial violations of human rights betrays the very purpose for which it exists and so forfeits not only its domestic legitimacy. In cases of humanitarian intervention, the interveners are supposed to take sides. Humanitarian intervention and nonideal theory oxford. Often, geopolitical and commercial calculations were cloaked in the language of humanitarian intervention. It relies on twin assumptions of liberal moral and political theory. By affording a much deeper historical scope to the term realism, this article shows how realism cannot be damned uniformly by those writing and thinking about humanitarian intervention in the present period, and the role it holds in contemporary debates on humanitarian intervention. The papers in this volume offer an informative analysis of humanitarian intervention with real intellectual coherence. An indepth analysis of the theoretical arguments surrounding the issue of a legitimate motivation for humanitarian intervention demonstrate to what extent either altruism or nationalselfinterests are considered a righteous stimulus. The paper argues that while the adoption of r2p represents significant progress of the liberal. The moral basis of humanitarian intervention nardin 2002. The theory and practice of humanitarian intervention and the.
Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention. The legal basis for a military operation could be individual or collective state selfdefence, united nations security council resolution, humanitarian intervention, or at the invitation or consent of the host state. Pdf humanitarian intervention and nonideal theory ramon. Humanitarian intervention in the long nineteenth century. Jan 16, 20 by looking at both realism and liberalism, the paper also explores which international relations theory better explains humanitarian intervention and r2p. Abstract when is humanitarian intervention legitimate and how should such interventions be conducted. Pdf libya and criteria for humanitarian intervention. Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention by.
Pdf humanitarian intervention and just war theory nathan. However, although the interest for a state to intervene must be weighed up against the outcomes of the intervention and no personal agendas from outside states can influence such interactions. Humanitarian intervention, actions undertaken by an organization or organizations usually a state or a coalition of states that are intended to alleviate extensive human suffering within the borders of a sovereign state. Augustine and seventhcentury arguments by hugo grotius.
Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention by evan j. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice. The sovereignty debate and the theory of aggression 21 4. Humanitarian intervention and international security. Murphy assumes an international legal approach and identifies the threat or use of force by a state, group of states, or international organization primarily for the purpose of protecting the nationals of the target state from widespread deprivations of internationally recognized human rights 1996. Humanitarian intervention and the responsibility to. Proportionality and utility one place to begin a discussion of morality and humanitarian intervention is by framing it in the context of just war theory. Humanitarian intervention an overview sciencedirect topics. However, the goal of the intervention shifted from humanitarian to the goal of regime change and in the ensuing conflict in which nato supported armed rebels on. The intervention of britain, russia and france in the greek war of independence is regarded as the first armed intervention on humanitarian grounds in world history as depicted by publicists from wheaton onwards and it took place prior to the appearance of the new concept of humanitarian intervention. Intervention logic and theories of change center for theory. The first theory, which features prominently in grotiuss writings, asserts that natural law authorizes all states to punish violations of the law of nations, irrespective of where or against whom the violations occur, to preserve the integrity of. The morality of intervention in international theory.
On this broader understanding, humanitarian intervention should be. Abstract the aim of this paper is to define humanitarian intervention, to analyze its purpose and to evaluate its value in international law. Humanitarian intervention, by contrast, has dropped the nonintervention injunction and, by implication,the doctrine of impartiality if impartiality means that the interveners fail to take sides. The rule of law in an incoherent world ian hurd t he concept of humanitarian intervention has evolved as a subset of the laws governing the use of force and has very quickly come to occupy an institutional position alongside selfdefense and security council authorization as a legal and legitimate reason for. Humanitarian intervention and the responsibility to protect. In the post world war ii period the doctrine of humanitarian intervention has been the. Adam roberts defines humanitarian intervention as a military intervention in a state, without the.
Sep, 20 by affording a much deeper historical scope to the term realism, this article shows how realism cannot be damned uniformly by those writing and thinking about humanitarian intervention in the present period, and the role it holds in contemporary debates on humanitarian intervention. Such an approach, it is argued, involves empirically scrutinizing two. Given appropriate circum stances, the impetus to urge and support such armed intervention among many of those sincerely concerned with continuing human rights violations and persecutions will surely reemerge. Jun, 2016 crisis theory and types of crisis posted on june, 2016 november 25, 2018 by dustin there are a variety of crisis theory and crisis intervention models used to explain how crises develop and what it means for an individual to need crisis intervention. The burden to be met 24 just cause 24 right authority. Theory of change is the approach we recommend to provide basic standards of needed components and structure because it is the most thorough, and can be graphically organized to be readable and actionable. This chapter discusses the implications these two theories have for when, why, and under what conditions, humanitarian intervention is morally permissible, and judges the extent to which each theory employs moral reasoning that treats human wellbeing as the highest moral. The problem of humanitarian intervention after the cold war 36. Humanitarian intervention has been defined as a states use of military force against another state, with publicly stating its goal is to end human rights violations in that state. Through a brief overview of standardized political theory, i justified humanitarian intervention as a moral requirement for humanity. From humanitarian intervention to the responsibility to. It argues that whilst these principles do not determine the.
This definition may be too narrow as it precludes nonmilitary forms of intervention such as humanitarian aid and international sanctions. It also discusses the fastestmoving normative development of modern times. This is the extension of fourthcentury arguments by st. This chapter argues that the philosophical debate around humanitarian intervention would be improved if it were less idealtheoretic. Humanitarian intervention has become a major focus of debate within governments, international organizations, and think tanks and across a variety of academic fields, including international and comparative law, international relations, political science, and moral and political philosophy.
The moral basis of humanitarian intervention terry nardin he is the author of law, morality, and the relations of states 1983 and the philosophy of michael oakeshott 2001, as well as editor with chris brown and nicholas rengger of international relations in political thought. These tensions are reflected in the definitions of humanitarian intervention. Humanitarian intervention ethical,legal,andpoliticaldilemmas edited by j. The theory and practice of humanitarian intervention and. It even has greater exercises to be conducted in contemporary international political governance if and only if the implementation is as attractive and good as the instrument. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect.
Whether the humanitarian intervention cases of the postcold war era were driven by altruistic or by selfinterested considerations is a question is covered within and enables a comprehensive and holistic evaluation of the question of what motivates western democracies to intervene or to abstain from intervention in humanitarian crises. The issue of humanitarian intervention has generated one of the most heated debates in international relations over the past decade, for both theorists and practitioners. The just war tradition encompasses an extensive literature on the general. Crisis theory and types of crisis dustin k macdonald. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice seminar 2nd term 20142015 organized by dirk moses hec and jennifer welsh sps mondays 11. Texts from the ancient greeks to the first world war 2002. In fact, one of the re c u rrent conundrums in political theory. This edited collection examines the challenges to international society posed by. The legal status of humanitarian interventionand its relationship to international humanitarian law humanitarian intervention is a jus ad bellumquestion.
The position of the international court of justice 83 2. The humanitarian part of the equation speaks to the motivation, and intervention implies the absence of the. The interdisciplinarity of the contributions, the sensitivity to the phenomenon of weak states, and the recognition of the tensions between human rights and the war on terrorism, combine to make this book both timely and welcome. The theoretical puzzles of humanitarian intervention can be well explained in. Chapter vii allows the security council to take action in situations. Humanitarian intervention is imbued with adversarial and negative. This article explores three theories of humanitarian intervention that appear in, or are inspired by, the writings of hugo grotius.
Aug 30, 2006 the moral basis of humanitarian intervention terry nardin he is the author of law, morality, and the relations of states 1983 and the philosophy of michael oakeshott 2001, as well as editor with chris brown and nicholas rengger of international relations in political thought. This article looks at the use of military force to protect human beings, or humanitarian intervention. The liberal case for humanitarian intervention by fernando r. Mednicoff university of massachusetts, amherst the contemporary international law of war is torn between the pressure to incorporate a doctrine to legitimize limited armed humanitarian intervention and its traditional concerns for nations sovereignty. Humanitarian intervention on its face incompatible with article 24 81 2. The liberal case for humanitarian intervention by fernando. Exploring the alternatives 28 the prospects for success 29 5. Hi to cover a topic not usually addressed, namely, the question of the scope of jus tified hi. Kosovo and the law of humanitarian intervention american. The first theory, which features prominently in grotiuss writings, asserts that natural law authorizes all states to punish violations of the law of nations, irrespective of where or against whom the violations occur, to preserve the integrity of international law. A theoretical assessment of humanitarian intervention and r2p. This wording also serves to emphasize the fact that the forces engaged in the intervention are bound by humanitarian law in their military operations. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and. Humanitarian intervention is the use of military intervention in a state to achieve socioeconomic objectives, such as keeping people alive and communities functioning by providing basic necessities, without the approval of its authorities.
Such suffering tends to be the result of a government instigating, facilitating, or ignoring the abuse of groups falling within its jurisdiction. Humanitarian intervention and international relations. All five have an explicit pedigree in christian just war theory, but. Motivations for humanitarian intervention theoretical and.
Could humanitarian intervention be legally justified in extreme cases. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect, and. Humanitarian intervention is legitimate when it is directed at suppressing human rights abuses and complies with the doctrine of double effect. Crossborder military intervention is a recurring feature throughout history. Many tyrants then used sovereignty as a shield behind which to commit atrocities with impunity. Due attention should be paid to any specific legal provisions pertaining to a. The concept of humanitarian intervention international studies. This brief sheds light on the motivation of humanitarian intervention from a theoretical and empirical point of view. It concludes that state sovereignty coexisted with the principle of unilateral. Nov 26, 2001 it relies on twin assumptions of liberal moral and political theory. Humanitarian intervention essay sample new york essays. This article sets out eight liberal principles that underlie humanitarian intervention, some of them abstract principles of international ethics and others more concrete principles that apply specifically to humanitarian intervention.
The dilemma of humanitarian intervention muhammad hassan zia assistant professor university of the punjab gujranwala campus gujranwala, pakistan. As part of the international human rights revolution, the birth, theory and practice of humanitarian intervention is indeed a welcome venture. Humanitarian intervention is a use of military force to address extraordinary suffering of people, such as genocide or similar, largescale violation of basic of human rights, where peoples suffering results from their own governments actions or failures to act. After decolonization, developing countries embedded nonintervention as a peremptory norm. At its heart is the alleged tension between the principle of state sovereignty, and the evolving norms related to individual human rights. The paper argues that while the adoption of r2p represents significant progress of the liberal school, its effects on interventions have been limited. The humanitarian part of the equation speaks to the motivation, and intervention implies the absence of the target states consent. Humanitarian intervention is generally understood to be the transboundary use of military force in order to halt or avert largescale and grave human suffering, and is a subject that has attracted much scholarly attention in recent decades. By looking at both realism and liberalism, the paper also explores which international relations theory better explains humanitarian intervention and r2p.
Armed humanitarian intervention internet encyclopedia of. In this essay we shall examine the concept of humanitarian intervention. This paper presents and partly argues for a nonideal theoretic approach to the ethics of humanitarian intervention, focusing particularly on the cases of rwanda and kosovo. The evolution away from the discourse of humanitarian intervention, which had been so divisive, and toward the embrace of the new concept of the responsibility to protect has been a fascinating piece of intellectual history in its own right. Sutherland, in encyclopedia of forensic and legal medicine second edition, 2015. Though to date no single universally accepted definition of the term exist nor are its parameters agreed on, the more frequently cited definitions include that of ian brownlie, who described it as the threat or use of armed force by a statewith the object of protecting human rights 1, and wil d. One, in target states where humanitarian intervention is being considered, there are two distinct and easily identified groups. Feb 06, 2012 see fernando teson, humanitarian intervention. The article first examines humanitarian interventions by colonial powers during the nineteenth century.
549 84 1565 292 945 208 1003 1181 400 1406 390 532 515 491 679 1457 837 536 462 641 804 387 1135 1085 667 876 457 240 1034 258 1423 1446 1553 126 1126 1307 801 301 179 291 1300 1237 931 1304 113 1242 1207 468